Botox
is a popular aesthetic treatment used to soften the wrinkles on upper face
associated with show of emotions like frown, frustration and anger. But lately
we have been hearing reports that by softening these expression lines most
people also get the added benefit of mood improvement. Theoretically it makes
sense, if you look angry, tired and depressed you are likely to act it too. To
prove this theory one of the first studies has been conducted at the Hannover Medical
School in Germany where the investigators found that treating the facial
muscles involved in emotion with Botulinum alleviates depressive symptoms.
Reporting
the results of his study at a press conference at the American Psychiatric
Association's 2014 Annual Meeting study’s lead investigator Prof. Tillmann
Kruger explained, "Our emotions are expressed by facial muscles, which in
turn send feedback signals to the brain to reinforce those emotions. Treating
facial muscles with Botulinum toxin interrupts this cycle".
Botox For Depression A Novel
Approach
A
previous open case series showed that depression remitted or improved in
patients who had undergone BTX treatment for glabellar frown lines. Following
this lead the investigators, decided to study the positive effects on mood post
such a treatment. To confirm these results, Dr. Kruger and colleague M. Axel
Wollmer, MD, from the Asklepios Clinic North Ochsenzoll in Hamburg, Germany,
conducted a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of BTX injection
as an adjunctive treatment for major depression.
A
total of 30 patients with high levels of chronic and treatment-resistant
depression were enrolled in the study. Patients were randomly assigned to
receive a single injection of BTX or a single injection of saline placebo.
The
study's primary end point was a change from baseline in depressive symptoms, as
measured by the 17-item Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HAMD17), during the
16-week study.
Six
weeks after a single treatment, the BTX group experienced an average 47.1%
reduction in HAMD17 scores vs 9.2% in the placebo group.
The
investigators found that the effect improved even further at the end of the
study and that treatment-dependent clinical improvement was also reflected in
the Beck Depression Inventory and the Clinical Global Impressions Scale.
At
the end of the study the investigators concluded that, "This study shows
that a single treatment of the glabellar region with Botulinum toxin may
shortly accomplish a strong and sustained alleviation of depression in patients
who did not improve sufficiently on previous medication. It supports the
concept that the facial musculature not only expresses but also regulates mood
states."
Dr.
Kruger is positively hopeful in commenting that BTX may offer a "novel,
effective, well-accepted, and economic therapeutic tool for the treatment of
major depression."
These
findings have since been replicated in 2 subsequent studies, one by Michelle
Magid, MD, and colleagues, which was presented in March at the American Academy
of Dermatology 72nd Annual Meeting and reported by
Medscape Medical News at that time, and the other by Eric Finzi, MD, PhD, and
colleagues, which was published in the May issue of Journal of Psychiatric
Research and was also reported by Medscape Medical News.
Dr.
Kruger and his colleagues are currently conducting a meta-analysis of the 3 randomized
trials in an effort to "further corroborate this novel treatment
approach." The researchers are also testing BTX's therapeutic potential in
other psychiatric disorders.
Moderating
the press conference and commenting on this particular study Jeffrey Borenstein,
MD, president and CEO of the Brain and Behavior Research Foundation in New York
City and chair of the American Psychiatric Association's Council on
Communications, reflected that pursuing new treatments for depression is crucial
and that he would like to see this line of research pursued in studies that
include larger numbers of patients.
We
await further results from such studies that can provide us with further
concrete evidence that botox indeed can change how depression is treated and
how change in appearance can positively affect human behavior.